How Patients Choose Healthcare Providers…and What It Means for Service Line Marketing

Jean Hitchcock  |  February 4, 2026

Associations • Branding • Healthcare • Tips

How Patients Choose Healthcare Providers…and What It Means for Service Line Marketing

By Jean Hitchcock

For every healthcare chief marketing officer, the same fundamental question applies to every service line: would patients choose your organization for their care…and why? 

Whether the service is cardiac care, oncology, neurology, or orthopedics, patient choice is shaped long before a campaign launches. Brand perception, clinical reputation, access, physician credibility, and patient experience all influence how patients evaluate healthcare providers in their market. 

Understanding how your organization, and each individual service line, stacks up against competitors is essential if your goal is to grow volume.  

Without a clear view of brand strength, differentiation, and readiness, marketing dollars risk being spent inefficiently or, worse, amplifying service lines that cannot deliver a competitive patient experience. 

Because no healthcare organization has unlimited marketing resources, service line marketing must be strategic. High-potential and high-value services should be prioritized, while underperforming lines must be strengthened operationally before being taken to market.  

Effective service line marketing begins not with promotion, but with clarity. 

How Patients Choose Care
How do patients choose a healthcare provider? 

Patients choose healthcare providers based on a combination of perceived clinical excellence, access to care, physician reputation, patient experience, and brand trust. In many cases, these perceptions are formed before a patient ever interacts with marketing—through referrals, online reviews, rankings, and reputation within the community. 

What is service line marketing in healthcare? 

Service line marketing focuses on promoting specific clinical services—such as cardiology, oncology, or orthopedics—rather than the health system as a whole. Effective service line marketing aligns clinical differentiation, operational readiness, and patient experience with targeted messaging designed to drive patient choice and volume growth.

When should a healthcare organization invest in service line marketing? 

Healthcare organizations should invest in service line marketing only when a service line has: 

  • Demonstrated clinical quality or differentiation 
  • Adequate capacity and access to meet increased demand 
  • A strong or improving patient experience 
  • Physician leadership willing to champion the service 

Marketing a service line that lacks capacity or delivers a poor patient experience can damage brand trust and reduce long-term growth. 

What factors determine whether a service line is ready to go to market? 

A service line is ready for marketing when it can clearly articulate its value to patients and deliver on that promise operationally. Key readiness factors include: 

  • Competitive clinical outcomes or recognition 
  • Physician recruitment or leadership strength 
  • Referral network integrity and minimal leakage 
  • Timely access to care 
  • Consistently positive patient experience scores 
Why does patient experience matter in service line growth? 

Patient experience directly influences reputation, referrals, and future demand. Marketing a service line with a poor patient experience increases visibility—but also increases exposure to shortcomings. Patients typically give healthcare organizations only one chance to make a good impression. 

Before investing in service line marketing, healthcare organizations must understand how patients perceive their care, how they compare to competitors, and whether the service line is operationally prepared for growth.

Is Your Service Line Ready for Marketing?

Healthcare leaders should evaluate service line readiness before investing in marketing. This framework outlines the five factors that determine whether a service line can grow without damaging brand trust.

The Service Line Marketing Readiness Framework

1. Clinical Credibility
Are outcomes, quality scores, or accreditations competitive in your market?
Do patients and referring physicians perceive the service as clinically excellent?
2. Access & Capacity
Can new patients be seen in a timely manner?
Are staffing, scheduling, and facilities sufficient to support increased demand?
3. Patient Experience
Are patient experience scores strong and consistent across the journey?
Are there known friction points that could worsen with increased volume?
4. Physician Leadership & Advocacy
Is there a physician champion willing to actively support the service line?
Can clinicians clearly articulate why patients should choose this service?
5. Market Differentiation
Does the service line offer something meaningfully different from competitors?
Is the value proposition clear to patients—not just clinicians?

If a service line cannot meet these five criteria, marketing should wait until operational or experience gaps are addressed.

A Head Start: How Organizational Brands Influence Service Line Perception

Your service line brands may get a boost from your overall organizational or system branding.  

For example, if you have “Saint” in your name, patients automatically feel that your care is more compassionate. 

Patients assume that an organization designated a Level 1 Trauma Center can handle the most challenging medical cases. 

If you are a “Children’s Hospital,” you can do no wrong in the minds of consumers. Children’s Hospitals are like Switzerland.  

If you have a strong neuroscience division, patients will believe that you can do anything clinically. If you’re skilled at the head, they’ll assume that everything else follows—it’s anthropology. 

Service lines to which these apply may benefit from a halo effect. Otherwise, your service line may need additional marketing support. 

First Steps First: Evaluating Service Lines Before Marketing Investment

When looking at your service lines, make sure you have done your homework before deciding where to concentrate your marketing dollars. 

Understand how each service line compares with competitors’ offerings. Review what criteria you use to determine which service is ready to go to market, and what services are profitable. 

Evaluate the differentiators each service line has that matter to patients. Consider accolades for clinical, nursing, or outcomes, and whether there are any key physician recruitments that enhance your offering. Assess whether you have a physician willing and able to champion the service line with whom you can partner. 

Referrals are always key to growth. Make sure you know what the referral network looks like in your market. Track the network integrity of your medical group—a.k.a. “leakage”—to make sure you’re keeping referrals within your system. Look at access to each service line—it does no good to boost volume for a line that does not have the capacity to take on more patients in a timely manner. 

Most importantly, map every step of the patient’s journey. Look at the patient experience scores. Patients only give you one chance to make a good impression, and marketing a service line with a poor experience can do more harm than good by exposing more people to the deficiencies. 

Marketing and Operations have to lead the charge internally before you can go to market. Make sure you have answers to all of these points and others before meeting with the service line physicians and staff. 

Tips from a CMO: Best Practices for Service Line Marketing ROI
  1. Make a rule: no marketing dollars for a service line with a poor patient experience or without capacity. 
  1. Map the patient journey from initial need to discharge and follow-up, and make sure the patient can find you at every step of the way via your website, call center, or ratings group. 
  1. Insist on an active physician partner to champion each service line campaign. 
  1. Engage all stakeholders in your marketing campaigns—friends and family will inquire. Use campaign summaries to make sure internal communications are part of any major campaign. 
  1. Establish how you will track ROI up front. It can be stated in many ways. 
  1. Once a service line campaign is over, report out on your success to the entire system. This will encourage other service lines to do what they need to do to replicate the great results. 
Reflection Prompt for Healthcare Leaders 

Before launching a service line campaign, take a moment to reflect:

  • If a patient needed this care today, would they choose us—based on what they see, hear, and experience?
  • Are we confident that access, capacity, and patient experience will support increased demand?
  • Can our physicians and staff clearly articulate why this service line stands apart?
  • Are we using marketing to accelerate a strong service line—or to compensate for gaps that need to be addressed internally?

Service line marketing is most effective when these questions can be answered honestly and consistently across Marketing, Operations, and clinical leadership.

Alignment at this stage improves campaign performance, protects patient trust, and strengthens the brand over time.

Ready to Strengthen Your Healthcare Brand?

If your organization is ready to align culture, patient experience, and growth under one brand strategy, we can help. → Talk to our healthcare branding team

Subscribe to the Ampersand Newsletter for insights from Yes&